Why Didn’t You Answer My Prayers?

I lost my only brother this week.

I prayed that God would heal him. I believed that God would heal him.

For over a year I’ve been writing about promises of faith throughout the Word of God. And I stood on every single one during my brother’s illness. I knew that God was able to heal him. I knew that fact with every fiber of my being.

With every negative medical report or turn for the worse, my faith never wavered. And I rejoiced in confidence with every good report from the doctors treating him. I fasted and prayed with my mother and sisters every day, waiting for my brother to recover.

On Resurrection Sunday, I spent the day joyfully commemorating Jesus rising from His grave, and I declared that because He woke up, my brother would too.

But on that Sunday evening, my brother took a turn for the worse. We’d been here before; it was time to start fervently praying and interceding for him again. I called my daughters downstairs, and along with my husband, we knelt in our family room and cried out for the Lord to save him. Surely, He would again respond to our collective intercession.

That’s what His word said, for us to come boldly before His throne to obtain mercy and find grace in our time of need (Hebrews 4:16). We were in desperate need of his mercy and grace!

While we were pleading with God, my phone buzzed again, informing me that my brother was gone. I held my daughters as they wailed in my arms. I was stunned. No tears fell in that moment. I was in a state of shock.

God didn’t answer my prayers, even though I prayed, I fasted, I declared and stood on His Word! I fought off fear throughout his sickness. I did everything spiritually that I knew to do. And yet my brother was still gone.

I had nothing to say to God. I didn’t want to pray; He hadn’t answered me anyway. No early morning prayer line, no daily devotional, no music – I just sat in my disappointment.

I still loved God, and still trusted Him, but He let me down and I had no words for Him. No praise, no adoration. I knew He was good. I had spoken a message previously, sharing that even through life’s disappointments, God was still good. Once again, it was testing time, to gauge if I truly believed the words I shared.

He wasn’t only good when He answered our prayers or blessed us the way we desired. If we believed He was good, then He was good all the time, even in our disappointment.

After a couple of days, my youngest daughter came into my room, laid next to me on my bed and asked, “Why did God have to take Uncle Ty?” I was still struggling with this question; how was I supposed to explain it to a twelve-year-old?

I thought a bit and gave her my interpretation on a message of comfort I heard six years earlier when my brother-in-law passed away unexpectedly.

I shared that when we got to heaven, that would be our new life, and we would live there forever. I told her that life on earth was just temporary, like a pregnancy. And that when someone died on earth, it was like their birthdate in heaven.

I explained that in the same way we welcomed her to our family on the day she was born, Jesus welcomed and held Tyrone when he woke up in heaven, and then handed him to God, and then our grandparents, and the rest of our relatives that left earth before us.

I contemplated aloud that he also probably met his niece or nephew, the baby that I miscarried before she was born. And that thought brought a quiet smile to both our faces.

Kass nodded her head as she took it all in. I asked her if that helped and she replied, “sort of”. So, I shared a personal story to help her further understand.

I told her about a virus that her older sister contracted before Kass was born, that gave her a bad case of diarrhea. Kennedi was about 18 months old. We had a morning tradition of bringing her into our bed where she enjoyed her sippy cup of milk shortly after waking up.

During her illness, we had been instructed not to give her milk, and instead replace it with Pedialyte so she wouldn’t become dehydrated.

I remember she would ask for her milk and just cry and cry and cry when we wouldn’t give it to her. I imagined her thinking – “Why won’t they give me my milk? They always give me my milk – don’t they love me?” But as her parent, I knew that milk would now harm her, instead of benefitting her.

I shared with Kass that sometimes God says no to something we really want, something we may even think we deserve, that we may think is good for us. And we really can’t understand why He would deny our prayer request.

But the same way that I withheld Kennedi’s milk from her, God may not always give us the things we ask for, because He knows better than we do. He can see the overall picture when we cannot.  But we must remember that He is our loving Father, and everything He does is for our good, even when we can’t understand or comprehend it.

Kennedi in her infantile state couldn’t understand my choice to withhold her milk, just like I couldn’t understand God’s decision not to answer my prayer for my brother the way I wanted Him to. But He knew best.

As I comforted my daughter, God in His gracious way comforted me (2 Corinthians 1:4). God answered our prayers, just not the way we expected Him to.

In heaven, Tyrone is healed completely. Even from the things that we couldn’t see or possibly know about in his mind and heart that needed healing.

I’m ready to talk to God again. And He was always there, patiently waiting on me to break the ice.


Is there an unanswered prayer that you are struggling with? Or is your life on a path that you simply can’t understand?

Decide to trust God’s answer, plan, and path, even if it is not what you prayed for, or had faith in.

Feel free to respond in the comments section… and share this story with someone in your life that could use the encouragement. 

 Follow Destined 4 the Dub for the Inspiration you need each week as you journey through the highs and lows of life!

51 thoughts on “Why Didn’t You Answer My Prayers?

  1. Praying for you and believing through this blog God is strengthening you as you have helped us once again!

    1. Beautiful. It’s amazing how children can help us thru our greatest grief. Helping comfort them, helps to comfort us. My boys did the same for me when my Dad died last year. Grief is so hard. Having God say no to what we want is hard too. It’s hard to utilize our faith when God has said no. We say we have faith, but standing on it is something else. Time heals if you let it. I pray for you and your family, and send so much love to you.

    2. Thank you so much! I shared the picture of our family from my dad’s pastoral anniversary with mom. It was such a blessing to her ❤️ Thank you for being you!

  2. This was truly beautiful and really shows how wonderful and personal your relationship is with God. I pray that as this has blessed me and many others that it will also start the healing process for you. I am so glad you were strong enough to write. I wish I could express how grateful I am for this blog because of the loss I have experienced over the last few days with people who have been very dear to me and touched my life including your brother. Praying for you still.

    1. Thank you Bishop. Praying for you and you walk through your loss, that you would go through each day with God’s peace and that you would feel His comfort stronger and stronger each day.

  3. What maturity. May God continue to give you His mind and words to share with us. Bless you Tanya.

  4. I pray that God will continue to bless you and strengthen you doing this time. This is so beautifully written…But God

  5. Thank you Tonya. Beautifully written and such an encouragment. Continue being the blessing to the world God created you to be.

  6. That was beautiful! Thank you for pushing past your own grief so that could encourage others. My prayers are with you and your family!

    1. Thank you. This was truly and answer to prayer, for God allow my pain to help someone else through theirs. He is so good, even when sometimes we may question Him.

    1. This was a Beautiful Example of Faith and Your Ability to minister through Your Own Grief. Ty was a Wonderful Man and I was Blessed to call him Friend. God Bless you and your family you all will be in my prayers💞🙏🏾

      1. Thank you so much Dionne ❤️ So thankful to God for his revelation to my heart as I was begging him for something to help me understand and get through this!

  7. Thanks so much for your post. I, admittedly have had to catch up on them. I allowed life to get in the way of this time I was once better at setting aside. But God knows how to slow us down and give us time to focus on what we need. First, I am continually praying for you and the entire family. I appreciate and applaud your strength and wisdom in this post and being open about where you were and where God is bringing you. You know I’ve shared before about prayers and wondering where God is when I’m waiting for answers. Thank you as always for offering another perspective and an important reminder, that God does answer, even if it’s not the answer we wanted, and that His ways are so far above our ways. We don’t know what He knows and sees when He makes His decisions and we only need to trust that His promises really are for our overall good. I needed that reminder! During such a difficult time in your life, I pray you know what a blessing it is, not just from your post, but from your life, that you can and have continued to encourage others. You truly embody the heart and the life style of your parents of giving and going past yourself. Love you!

    1. Thank you Sheera and love you too. On this journey I’m continually challenged to trust God more, when I already think I trust Him enough. I’m learning so much about myself and being strengthened through each challenge. I never thought I’d have to go through something like this, but God is faithful!

  8. Praying for you and your family! You have my deepest and heartfelt sympathy!🙏🙏🙏

  9. This message is so powerful. I thank you for sharing this. The words are speaking to my soul and helping me with the loss of my mother 6 months ago. Praying for you.

    1. Amia I am so grateful for this, I remember when your mom passed and all the pain you shared as you went through. To hear that this has provided help and hopefully comfort and peace is truly an answer to prayer ❤️

  10. As a Christian, this blog blessed me beyond belief. I loss both my brothers and both my parents, but I trust God. It’s not always easy to do
    and there are times when anger and grief will intermingle but God is the great comforter. I’m praying for you and your entire family.

  11. What a blessing and beautiful translation. May God continue bless you and your family through this difficult time.

  12. I am saddened by the loss of Tyrone not only was he one of my bosses, but a very good friend. I’m gonna miss him and miss making him laugh (with his serious face) and hearing him say you stupid.
    The Family and as well as my coworkers are in my prayers.
    Love you all

  13. This was so good. I went through so much when God didn’t answer my prayer the way I wanted him too. The revelation he has given you is your step into healing. Love you sis excellent blog

  14. This was touching and very real. I am praying for you and your family. God bless you.

  15. May God bless you and the entire May family. You have my deepest sympathy. I am new to the ministry of your writing. The transparency of your grief has touched my heart. It has encouraged me in my spiritual journey.

    1. Thank you so much for sharing this, it truly blessed my heart! I pray you will continue to follow the blog as my prayer is to always provided encouragement to my readers!

Leave a Reply